{"public_id": "34948336-73fe-46c9-926d-31338ef505f9", "version": 1, "title": "Turkish political traditions & movements", "owner": {"username": "onurmatik", "display_name": "onurmatik"}, "published_at": "2026-08-03T17:16:24.036000+00:00", "is_owner": false, "is_latest": true, "forked_from": null, "graph": {"meta": {"top_k": 3, "clusters": [{"id": 0, "size": 2, "label": "Republican institutional reformers", "rationale": "Both are Republican\u2011oriented doctrines focused on state\u2011centered secularism and reconfiguring Republican institutions and norms.", "member_ids": ["0", "12"], "exemplar_id": "0", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Kemalizm", "\u0130kinci Cumhuriyet\u00e7ilik"], "exemplar_label": "Kemalizm", "representative_ids": ["0", "12"], "representative_labels": ["Kemalizm", "\u0130kinci Cumhuriyet\u00e7ilik"]}, {"id": 1, "size": 6, "label": "Moderate electoral democratic traditions", "rationale": "All members are mainstream centre or centre\u2011left/centre\u2011right electoral currents stressing democratic practice, moderate reform, and market/social policy synthesis.", "member_ids": ["13", "10", "4", "14", "9", "7"], "exemplar_id": "4", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Demokrat Parti Gelene\u011fi", "Demokratik Sol", "Merkez sa\u011f", "Muhafazak\u00e2r Demokrasi", "Ortan\u0131n Solu", "Sosyal demokrasi"], "exemplar_label": "Merkez sa\u011f", "representative_ids": ["4", "9"], "representative_labels": ["Merkez sa\u011f", "Ortan\u0131n Solu"]}, {"id": 2, "size": 9, "label": "Ideological and activist political movements", "rationale": "Each entry is an organized ideological current or activist movement advocating a specific geopolitical, ethnic, religious, nationalist, or revolutionary program.", "member_ids": ["16", "11", "8", "6", "5", "2", "15", "1", "3"], "exemplar_id": "3", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Avrasyac\u0131l\u0131k", "Devrimci Yol", "K\u00fcrt hareketi", "Mill\u00ee G\u00f6r\u00fc\u015f", "Siyasal \u0130slam", "T\u00fcrk milliyet\u00e7ili\u011fi", "T\u00fcrk-\u0130slam Sentezi", "Ulusalc\u0131l\u0131k", "\u00dclk\u00fcc\u00fcl\u00fck"], "exemplar_label": "\u00dclk\u00fcc\u00fcl\u00fck", "representative_ids": ["3", "11"], "representative_labels": ["\u00dclk\u00fcc\u00fcl\u00fck", "Devrimci Yol"]}], "threshold": 0.42, "edge_count": 33, "input_mode": "concept_list", "node_count": 17, "final_count": 17, "input_count": 17, "layout_model": "set_centered_angular_mds_v1", "weight_curve": "square", "cluster_count": 3, "cluster_method": "average_linkage_fixed_count_v1", "distance_count": 136, "expanded_count": 0, "expansion_mode": "contextual_hybrid", "described_count": 17, "distance_metric": "cosine", "embedding_model": "text-embedding-3-large", "expansion_model": "", "generation_model": "gpt-5-mini", "centering_applied": true, "generation_source": "ai_seed", "projection_method": "classical_mds_2d", "projection_stress": 0.3454800326157355, "relationship_mode": "clustered", "anchor_suggestions": [{"label": "Secularism vs. Religiosity", "rationale": "degree to which public life and institutions are organized around secular norms versus religious authority and practice"}, {"label": "State\u2011Centric Order vs. Plural Autonomy", "rationale": "preference for strong centralized state control and unitary order contrasted with decentralization, minority rights, and autonomous social spheres"}, {"label": "Ethno\u2011national Exclusivity vs. Civic Inclusivity", "rationale": "tension between defining the polity by ethnic/cultural homogeneity and defining it by civic, legal, or territorial membership"}, {"label": "Reformist Modernization vs. Traditionalist Continuity", "rationale": "orientation toward transformative, often technocratic modernizing projects versus preserving traditional social, cultural, or religious continuities"}], "cluster_silhouette": 0.08053934406387721, "embedding_provider": "openai", "centering_min_items": 4, "embedding_dimensions": 1024, "embedding_input_type": "default", "cluster_label_version": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "coordinate_max_radius": 0.52, "relative_vector_model": "set_centered_l2_residuals", "cluster_min_silhouette": 0.08, "cluster_selection_mode": "fixed_count", "layout_distance_metric": "angular_distance_acos_over_pi", "embedding_input_version": "label_description_v1", "neighbor_preservation_k": 3, "relationship_mode_label": "Clustered", "requested_cluster_count": 3, "neighbor_preservation_at_3": 0.6274509803921569, "relative_similarity_metric": "cosine", "description_context_version": "semantic_neighborhood_single_sense_v2", "embedding_provider_requested": "openai", "projection_positive_eigenvalues": 16, "anchor": {"id": "9c525458-eea2-44b3-bbe0-b79e830c1574", "label": "Devlet", "model": "text-embedding-3-large", "provider": "openai", "rank_method": "descending_similarity", "score_method": "within_map_min_max", "similarity_max": 0.463093, "similarity_min": 0.302171, "similarity_metric": "cosine"}}, "edges": [{"source": "4", "target": "14", "weight": 0.502274, "similarity": 0.708713}, {"source": "4", "target": "9", "weight": 0.482404, "similarity": 0.694553}, {"source": "1", "target": "2", "weight": 0.436491, "similarity": 0.660675}, {"source": "9", "target": "10", "weight": 0.431834, "similarity": 0.657141}, {"source": "7", "target": "13", "weight": 0.42129, "similarity": 0.649068}, {"source": "1", "target": "3", "weight": 0.392595, "similarity": 0.626574}, {"source": "13", "target": "14", "weight": 0.382045, "similarity": 0.618098}, {"source": "3", "target": "11", "weight": 0.378644, "similarity": 0.615341}, {"source": "2", "target": "3", "weight": 0.37104, "similarity": 0.60913}, {"source": "5", "target": "6", "weight": 0.364629, "similarity": 0.603845}, {"source": "7", "target": "10", "weight": 0.357071, "similarity": 0.597554}, {"source": "7", "target": "14", "weight": 0.356888, "similarity": 0.597401}, {"source": "3", "target": "6", "weight": 0.352427, "similarity": 0.593656}, {"source": "2", "target": "15", "weight": 0.34521, "similarity": 0.587545}, {"source": "4", "target": "13", "weight": 0.343996, "similarity": 0.586512}, {"source": "4", "target": "10", "weight": 0.341652, "similarity": 0.58451}, {"source": "0", "target": "12", "weight": 0.335542, "similarity": 0.57926}, {"source": "6", "target": "15", "weight": 0.335431, "similarity": 0.579164}, {"source": "0", "target": "15", "weight": 0.330592, "similarity": 0.574972}, {"source": "0", "target": "2", "weight": 0.329418, "similarity": 0.57395}, {"source": "5", "target": "15", "weight": 0.322597, "similarity": 0.567977}, {"source": "12", "target": "14", "weight": 0.319118, "similarity": 0.564905}, {"source": "9", "target": "14", "weight": 0.316481, "similarity": 0.562567}, {"source": "10", "target": "11", "weight": 0.304605, "similarity": 0.55191}, {"source": "1", "target": "16", "weight": 0.303342, "similarity": 0.550765}, {"source": "9", "target": "11", "weight": 0.29195, "similarity": 0.540324}, {"source": "7", "target": "12", "weight": 0.286912, "similarity": 0.535642}, {"source": "3", "target": "8", "weight": 0.28339, "similarity": 0.532343}, {"source": "5", "target": "14", "weight": 0.271538, "similarity": 0.521093}, {"source": "1", "target": "8", "weight": 0.266239, "similarity": 0.515983}, {"source": "2", "target": "16", "weight": 0.260201, "similarity": 0.510099}, {"source": "15", "target": "16", "weight": 0.246012, "similarity": 0.495996}, {"source": "8", "target": "11", "weight": 0.239253, "similarity": 0.489135}], "nodes": [{"x": -0.291726, "y": -0.081136, "id": "0", "label": "Kemalizm", "degree": 3, "source": "user", "cluster": 0, "description": "foundational Republican ideology; state-centered secular nationalism emphasizing modernization and civic unity", "anchor_similarity": 0.463093, "anchor_score": 1.0, "anchor_rank": 1}, {"x": -0.185475, "y": 0.358402, "id": "1", "label": "Ulusalc\u0131l\u0131k", "degree": 4, "source": "user", "cluster": 2, "description": "nationalist movement tendency; emphasis on territorial integrity and ethno\u2011national identity in politics", "anchor_similarity": 0.377809, "anchor_score": 0.470028, "anchor_rank": 4}, {"x": -0.337563, "y": 0.269039, "id": "2", "label": "T\u00fcrk milliyet\u00e7ili\u011fi", "degree": 5, "source": "user", "cluster": 2, "description": "ethno\u2011nationalist current; prioritizes Turkish identity, cultural homogeneity, and nation-first policies", "anchor_similarity": 0.338038, "anchor_score": 0.222885, "anchor_rank": 14}, {"x": -0.182321, "y": 0.381312, "id": "3", "label": "\u00dclk\u00fcc\u00fcl\u00fck", "degree": 5, "source": "user", "cluster": 2, "description": "nationalist activist movement; radical/conservative Turkish nationalist activism with youth organizational culture", "anchor_similarity": 0.319864, "anchor_score": 0.109948, "anchor_rank": 16}, {"x": 0.340754, "y": -0.233196, "id": "4", "label": "Merkez sa\u011f", "degree": 4, "source": "user", "cluster": 1, "description": "electoral political orientation; moderate conservative parties combining market policies with social order", "anchor_similarity": 0.430678, "anchor_score": 0.79857, "anchor_rank": 2}, {"x": -0.268458, "y": -0.114712, "id": "5", "label": "Siyasal \u0130slam", "degree": 3, "source": "user", "cluster": 2, "description": "religiously oriented political current; public policy guided by Islamic norms and mobilization of pious constituencies", "anchor_similarity": 0.352818, "anchor_score": 0.314732, "anchor_rank": 12}, {"x": -0.332223, "y": -0.051239, "id": "6", "label": "Mill\u00ee G\u00f6r\u00fc\u015f", "degree": 3, "source": "user", "cluster": 2, "description": "Islamist political tradition; organized movement advocating political Islam with conservative social program", "anchor_similarity": 0.373937, "anchor_score": 0.445968, "anchor_rank": 5}, {"x": 0.249256, "y": -0.350571, "id": "7", "label": "Sosyal demokrasi", "degree": 4, "source": "user", "cluster": 1, "description": "progressive party tradition; emphasis on welfare state, social justice, and plural democratic norms", "anchor_similarity": 0.371022, "anchor_score": 0.427854, "anchor_rank": 6}, {"x": 0.068455, "y": 0.456638, "id": "8", "label": "K\u00fcrt hareketi", "degree": 3, "source": "user", "cluster": 2, "description": "ethno-political movement; Kurdish political organizations seeking cultural rights, regional autonomy, or self\u2011representation", "anchor_similarity": 0.322316, "anchor_score": 0.125185, "anchor_rank": 15}, {"x": 0.52, "y": 0.0, "id": "9", "label": "Ortan\u0131n Solu", "degree": 4, "source": "user", "cluster": 1, "description": "centre-left electoral label; pragmatic social-democratic platform oriented to moderate reform", "anchor_similarity": 0.350702, "anchor_score": 0.301583, "anchor_rank": 13}, {"x": 0.456047, "y": -0.045494, "id": "10", "label": "Demokratik Sol", "degree": 4, "source": "user", "cluster": 1, "description": "left\u2011of\u2011centre nationalist social democracy; combines state interventionist economics with secular nationalism", "anchor_similarity": 0.359782, "anchor_score": 0.358007, "anchor_rank": 9}, {"x": 0.283313, "y": 0.273031, "id": "11", "label": "Devrimci Yol", "degree": 4, "source": "user", "cluster": 2, "description": "radical left organization; Marxist\u2013Leninist revolutionary activism and extra\u2011parliamentary mobilization", "anchor_similarity": 0.355095, "anchor_score": 0.328883, "anchor_rank": 11}, {"x": -0.064201, "y": -0.197296, "id": "12", "label": "\u0130kinci Cumhuriyet\u00e7ilik", "degree": 3, "source": "user", "cluster": 0, "description": "constitutional reform discourse; advocates reconfiguring Republican institutions and political norms", "anchor_similarity": 0.361394, "anchor_score": 0.368022, "anchor_rank": 8}, {"x": 0.235756, "y": -0.425375, "id": "13", "label": "Demokrat Parti Gelene\u011fi", "degree": 3, "source": "user", "cluster": 1, "description": "conservative-populist lineage; legacy of centre-right populist democracy emphasizing rural constituencies and liberalized economy", "anchor_similarity": 0.302171, "anchor_score": 0.0, "anchor_rank": 17}, {"x": 0.063538, "y": -0.455146, "id": "14", "label": "Muhafazak\u00e2r Demokrasi", "degree": 6, "source": "user", "cluster": 1, "description": "moderate conservative current; synthesis of social conservatism with democratic norms and market policies", "anchor_similarity": 0.394023, "anchor_score": 0.570788, "anchor_rank": 3}, {"x": -0.463991, "y": 0.024789, "id": "15", "label": "T\u00fcrk-\u0130slam Sentezi", "degree": 5, "source": "user", "cluster": 2, "description": "ideological synthesis doctrine; blending Turkish nationalism with Sunni Islamic cultural frameworks", "anchor_similarity": 0.35863, "anchor_score": 0.35085, "anchor_rank": 10}, {"x": -0.091162, "y": 0.190955, "id": "16", "label": "Avrasyac\u0131l\u0131k", "degree": 3, "source": "user", "cluster": 2, "description": "geopolitical school; advocacy for Eurasian strategic orientation and civilizational regionalism", "anchor_similarity": 0.370304, "anchor_score": 0.423395, "anchor_rank": 7}], "distances": [{"source": "0", "target": "1", "distance": 0.456864, "similarity": 0.543136, "layout_distance": 0.49289, "relative_similarity": 0.022334}, {"source": "0", "target": "2", "distance": 0.42605, "similarity": 0.57395, "layout_distance": 0.465265, "relative_similarity": 0.108906}, {"source": "0", "target": "3", "distance": 0.464627, "similarity": 0.535373, "layout_distance": 0.509887, "relative_similarity": -0.031057}, {"source": "0", "target": "4", "distance": 0.51222, "similarity": 0.48778, "layout_distance": 0.555151, "relative_similarity": -0.172397}, {"source": "0", "target": "5", "distance": 0.572812, "similarity": 0.427188, "layout_distance": 0.539836, "relative_similarity": -0.124821}, {"source": "0", "target": "6", "distance": 0.499023, "similarity": 0.500977, "layout_distance": 0.520244, "relative_similarity": -0.063556}, {"source": "0", "target": "7", "distance": 0.516951, "similarity": 0.483049, "layout_distance": 0.525715, "relative_similarity": -0.080699}, {"source": "0", "target": "8", "distance": 0.632399, "similarity": 0.367601, "layout_distance": 0.554995, "relative_similarity": -0.171915}, {"source": "0", "target": "9", "distance": 0.602128, "similarity": 0.397872, "layout_distance": 0.581385, "relative_similarity": -0.252901}, {"source": "0", "target": "10", "distance": 0.52008, "similarity": 0.47992, "layout_distance": 0.525331, "relative_similarity": -0.079496}, {"source": "0", "target": "11", "distance": 0.528615, "similarity": 0.471385, "layout_distance": 0.528597, "relative_similarity": -0.089718}, {"source": "0", "target": "12", "distance": 0.42074, "similarity": 0.57926, "layout_distance": 0.464804, "relative_similarity": 0.110345}, {"source": "0", "target": "13", "distance": 0.554031, "similarity": 0.445969, "layout_distance": 0.527042, "relative_similarity": -0.084854}, {"source": "0", "target": "14", "distance": 0.487133, "similarity": 0.512867, "layout_distance": 0.535628, "relative_similarity": -0.111695}, {"source": "0", "target": "15", "distance": 0.425028, "similarity": 0.574972, "layout_distance": 0.459732, "relative_similarity": 0.126167}, {"source": "0", "target": "16", "distance": 0.558953, "similarity": 0.441047, "layout_distance": 0.526684, "relative_similarity": -0.083731}, {"source": "1", "target": "2", "distance": 0.339325, "similarity": 0.660675, "layout_distance": 0.410336, "relative_similarity": 0.277977}, {"source": "1", "target": "3", "distance": 0.373426, "similarity": 0.626574, "layout_distance": 0.450103, "relative_similarity": 0.156114}, {"source": "1", "target": "4", "distance": 0.515795, "similarity": 0.484205, "layout_distance": 0.565062, "relative_similarity": -0.202977}, {"source": "1", "target": "5", "distance": 0.573052, "similarity": 0.426948, "layout_distance": 0.545977, "relative_similarity": -0.143938}, {"source": "1", "target": "6", "distance": 0.485092, "similarity": 0.514908, "layout_distance": 0.516642, "relative_similarity": -0.052257}, {"source": "1", "target": "7", "distance": 0.544257, "similarity": 0.455743, "layout_distance": 0.5504, "relative_similarity": -0.157675}, {"source": "1", "target": "8", "distance": 0.484017, "similarity": 0.515983, "layout_distance": 0.470979, "relative_similarity": 0.091047}, {"source": "1", "target": "9", "distance": 0.555523, "similarity": 0.444477, "layout_distance": 0.556334, "relative_similarity": -0.176055}, {"source": "1", "target": "10", "distance": 0.534728, "similarity": 0.465272, "layout_distance": 0.541234, "relative_similarity": -0.129179}, {"source": "1", "target": "11", "distance": 0.573495, "similarity": 0.426505, "layout_distance": 0.564969, "relative_similarity": -0.202692}, {"source": "1", "target": "12", "distance": 0.503512, "similarity": 0.496488, "layout_distance": 0.526602, "relative_similarity": -0.083477}, {"source": "1", "target": "13", "distance": 0.635023, "similarity": 0.364977, "layout_distance": 0.585205, "relative_similarity": -0.264495}, {"source": "1", "target": "14", "distance": 0.518674, "similarity": 0.481326, "layout_distance": 0.566135, "relative_similarity": -0.206278}, {"source": "1", "target": "15", "distance": 0.49619, "similarity": 0.50381, "layout_distance": 0.512005, "relative_similarity": -0.037704}, {"source": "1", "target": "16", "distance": 0.449235, "similarity": 0.550765, "layout_distance": 0.4631, "relative_similarity": 0.115666}, {"source": "2", "target": "3", "distance": 0.39087, "similarity": 0.60913, "layout_distance": 0.455958, "relative_similarity": 0.13792}, {"source": "2", "target": "4", "distance": 0.519802, "similarity": 0.480198, "layout_distance": 0.558514, "relative_similarity": -0.182793}, {"source": "2", "target": "5", "distance": 0.597807, "similarity": 0.402193, "layout_distance": 0.553708, "relative_similarity": -0.167928}, {"source": "2", "target": "6", "distance": 0.475748, "similarity": 0.524252, "layout_distance": 0.502649, "relative_similarity": -0.008323}, {"source": "2", "target": "7", "distance": 0.598134, "similarity": 0.401866, "layout_distance": 0.57833, "relative_similarity": -0.243605}, {"source": "2", "target": "8", "distance": 0.515285, "similarity": 0.484715, "layout_distance": 0.483741, "relative_similarity": 0.051056}, {"source": "2", "target": "9", "distance": 0.620193, "similarity": 0.379807, "layout_distance": 0.591492, "relative_similarity": -0.283488}, {"source": "2", "target": "10", "distance": 0.565188, "similarity": 0.434812, "layout_distance": 0.553337, "relative_similarity": -0.166781}, {"source": "2", "target": "11", "distance": 0.591279, "similarity": 0.408721, "layout_distance": 0.568114, "relative_similarity": -0.212358}, {"source": "2", "target": "12", "distance": 0.536542, "similarity": 0.463458, "layout_distance": 0.540946, "relative_similarity": -0.128281}, {"source": "2", "target": "13", "distance": 0.63024, "similarity": 0.36976, "layout_distance": 0.573225, "relative_similarity": -0.228019}, {"source": "2", "target": "14", "distance": 0.513341, "similarity": 0.486659, "layout_distance": 0.552698, "relative_similarity": -0.1648}, {"source": "2", "target": "15", "distance": 0.412455, "similarity": 0.587545, "layout_distance": 0.449963, "relative_similarity": 0.15655}, {"source": "2", "target": "16", "distance": 0.489901, "similarity": 0.510099, "layout_distance": 0.482382, "relative_similarity": 0.05532}, {"source": "3", "target": "4", "distance": 0.511314, "similarity": 0.488686, "layout_distance": 0.577241, "relative_similarity": -0.240286}, {"source": "3", "target": "5", "distance": 0.507537, "similarity": 0.492463, "layout_distance": 0.515238, "relative_similarity": -0.047853}, {"source": "3", "target": "6", "distance": 0.406344, "similarity": 0.593656, "layout_distance": 0.472714, "relative_similarity": 0.085616}, {"source": "3", "target": "7", "distance": 0.55238, "similarity": 0.44762, "layout_distance": 0.570099, "relative_similarity": -0.218446}, {"source": "3", "target": "8", "distance": 0.467657, "similarity": 0.532343, "layout_distance": 0.470043, "relative_similarity": 0.093975}, {"source": "3", "target": "9", "distance": 0.561369, "similarity": 0.438631, "layout_distance": 0.574615, "relative_similarity": -0.23227}, {"source": "3", "target": "10", "distance": 0.558192, "similarity": 0.441808, "layout_distance": 0.571298, "relative_similarity": -0.22212}, {"source": "3", "target": "11", "distance": 0.384659, "similarity": 0.615341, "layout_distance": 0.447333, "relative_similarity": 0.164703}, {"source": "3", "target": "12", "distance": 0.510447, "similarity": 0.489553, "layout_distance": 0.544509, "relative_similarity": -0.139373}, {"source": "3", "target": "13", "distance": 0.56997, "similarity": 0.43003, "layout_distance": 0.555752, "relative_similarity": -0.174257}, {"source": "3", "target": "14", "distance": 0.504696, "similarity": 0.495304, "layout_distance": 0.570817, "relative_similarity": -0.220649}, {"source": "3", "target": "15", "distance": 0.445677, "similarity": 0.554323, "layout_distance": 0.489032, "relative_similarity": 0.034449}, {"source": "3", "target": "16", "distance": 0.546045, "similarity": 0.453955, "layout_distance": 0.536052, "relative_similarity": -0.113018}, {"source": "4", "target": "5", "distance": 0.521219, "similarity": 0.478781, "layout_distance": 0.534399, "relative_similarity": -0.107856}, {"source": "4", "target": "6", "distance": 0.46955, "similarity": 0.53045, "layout_distance": 0.52871, "relative_similarity": -0.090072}, {"source": "4", "target": "7", "distance": 0.433624, "similarity": 0.566376, "layout_distance": 0.49537, "relative_similarity": 0.014544}, {"source": "4", "target": "8", "distance": 0.565218, "similarity": 0.434782, "layout_distance": 0.541186, "relative_similarity": -0.12903}, {"source": "4", "target": "9", "distance": 0.305447, "similarity": 0.694553, "layout_distance": 0.399396, "relative_similarity": 0.31082}, {"source": "4", "target": "10", "distance": 0.41549, "similarity": 0.58451, "layout_distance": 0.479829, "relative_similarity": 0.063328}, {"source": "4", "target": "11", "distance": 0.487981, "similarity": 0.512019, "layout_distance": 0.529593, "relative_similarity": -0.092835}, {"source": "4", "target": "12", "distance": 0.478421, "similarity": 0.521579, "layout_distance": 0.532284, "relative_similarity": -0.101249}, {"source": "4", "target": "13", "distance": 0.413488, "similarity": 0.586512, "layout_distance": 0.459683, "relative_similarity": 0.126321}, {"source": "4", "target": "14", "distance": 0.291287, "similarity": 0.708713, "layout_distance": 0.41239, "relative_similarity": 0.271772}, {"source": "4", "target": "15", "distance": 0.56807, "similarity": 0.43193, "layout_distance": 0.586884, "relative_similarity": -0.269578}, {"source": "4", "target": "16", "distance": 0.516706, "similarity": 0.483294, "layout_distance": 0.526503, "relative_similarity": -0.083164}, {"source": "5", "target": "6", "distance": 0.396155, "similarity": 0.603845, "layout_distance": 0.431607, "relative_similarity": 0.213213}, {"source": "5", "target": "7", "distance": 0.550896, "similarity": 0.449104, "layout_distance": 0.524102, "relative_similarity": -0.075645}, {"source": "5", "target": "8", "distance": 0.582079, "similarity": 0.417921, "layout_distance": 0.504448, "relative_similarity": -0.013972}, {"source": "5", "target": "9", "distance": 0.61188, "similarity": 0.38812, "layout_distance": 0.560737, "relative_similarity": -0.189655}, {"source": "5", "target": "10", "distance": 0.61398, "similarity": 0.38602, "layout_distance": 0.561159, "relative_similarity": -0.190958}, {"source": "5", "target": "11", "distance": 0.544691, "similarity": 0.455309, "layout_distance": 0.515799, "relative_similarity": -0.049613}, {"source": "5", "target": "12", "distance": 0.542212, "similarity": 0.457788, "layout_distance": 0.522321, "relative_similarity": -0.070066}, {"source": "5", "target": "13", "distance": 0.641349, "similarity": 0.358651, "layout_distance": 0.556806, "relative_similarity": -0.177517}, {"source": "5", "target": "14", "distance": 0.478907, "similarity": 0.521093, "layout_distance": 0.504561, "relative_similarity": -0.014327}, {"source": "5", "target": "15", "distance": 0.432023, "similarity": 0.567977, "layout_distance": 0.445705, "relative_similarity": 0.169748}, {"source": "5", "target": "16", "distance": 0.58685, "similarity": 0.41315, "layout_distance": 0.521493, "relative_similarity": -0.06747}, {"source": "6", "target": "7", "distance": 0.534761, "similarity": 0.465239, "layout_distance": 0.542419, "relative_similarity": -0.132868}, {"source": "6", "target": "8", "distance": 0.564633, "similarity": 0.435367, "layout_distance": 0.518496, "relative_similarity": -0.058076}, {"source": "6", "target": "9", "distance": 0.547595, "similarity": 0.452405, "layout_distance": 0.549405, "relative_similarity": -0.154589}, {"source": "6", "target": "10", "distance": 0.598943, "similarity": 0.401057, "layout_distance": 0.583635, "relative_similarity": -0.259735}, {"source": "6", "target": "11", "distance": 0.544437, "similarity": 0.455563, "layout_distance": 0.543795, "relative_similarity": -0.137154}, {"source": "6", "target": "12", "distance": 0.518386, "similarity": 0.481614, "layout_distance": 0.535381, "relative_similarity": -0.110926}, {"source": "6", "target": "13", "distance": 0.562907, "similarity": 0.437093, "layout_distance": 0.537064, "relative_similarity": -0.116178}, {"source": "6", "target": "14", "distance": 0.482668, "similarity": 0.517332, "layout_distance": 0.537474, "relative_similarity": -0.117456}, {"source": "6", "target": "15", "distance": 0.420836, "similarity": 0.579164, "layout_distance": 0.460593, "relative_similarity": 0.123486}, {"source": "6", "target": "16", "distance": 0.563522, "similarity": 0.436478, "layout_distance": 0.533892, "relative_similarity": -0.106274}, {"source": "7", "target": "8", "distance": 0.647848, "similarity": 0.352152, "layout_distance": 0.562227, "relative_similarity": -0.19425}, {"source": "7", "target": "9", "distance": 0.454373, "similarity": 0.545627, "layout_distance": 0.480849, "relative_similarity": 0.060127}, {"source": "7", "target": "10", "distance": 0.402446, "similarity": 0.597554, "layout_distance": 0.445757, "relative_similarity": 0.169587}, {"source": "7", "target": "11", "distance": 0.547053, "similarity": 0.452947, "layout_distance": 0.538654, "relative_similarity": -0.121138}, {"source": "7", "target": "12", "distance": 0.464358, "similarity": 0.535642, "layout_distance": 0.492362, "relative_similarity": 0.023992}, {"source": "7", "target": "13", "distance": 0.350932, "similarity": 0.649068, "layout_distance": 0.397187, "relative_similarity": 0.317409}, {"source": "7", "target": "14", "distance": 0.402599, "similarity": 0.597401, "layout_distance": 0.472002, "relative_similarity": 0.087845}, {"source": "7", "target": "15", "distance": 0.627604, "similarity": 0.372396, "layout_distance": 0.591293, "relative_similarity": -0.282889}, {"source": "7", "target": "16", "distance": 0.597855, "similarity": 0.402145, "layout_distance": 0.548867, "relative_similarity": -0.152918}, {"source": "8", "target": "9", "distance": 0.56516, "similarity": 0.43484, "layout_distance": 0.511671, "relative_similarity": -0.036659}, {"source": "8", "target": "10", "distance": 0.630925, "similarity": 0.369075, "layout_distance": 0.549671, "relative_similarity": -0.155413}, {"source": "8", "target": "11", "distance": 0.510865, "similarity": 0.489135, "layout_distance": 0.477326, "relative_similarity": 0.071172}, {"source": "8", "target": "12", "distance": 0.604506, "similarity": 0.395494, "layout_distance": 0.540019, "relative_similarity": -0.125392}, {"source": "8", "target": "13", "distance": 0.709972, "similarity": 0.290028, "layout_distance": 0.575178, "relative_similarity": -0.233989}, {"source": "8", "target": "14", "distance": 0.611005, "similarity": 0.388995, "layout_distance": 0.570329, "relative_similarity": -0.21915}, {"source": "8", "target": "15", "distance": 0.610098, "similarity": 0.389902, "layout_distance": 0.534322, "relative_similarity": -0.107617}, {"source": "8", "target": "16", "distance": 0.575848, "similarity": 0.424152, "layout_distance": 0.497399, "relative_similarity": 0.00817}, {"source": "9", "target": "10", "distance": 0.342859, "similarity": 0.657141, "layout_distance": 0.404416, "relative_similarity": 0.295795}, {"source": "9", "target": "11", "distance": 0.459676, "similarity": 0.540324, "layout_distance": 0.480171, "relative_similarity": 0.062255}, {"source": "9", "target": "12", "distance": 0.511463, "similarity": 0.488537, "layout_distance": 0.522294, "relative_similarity": -0.069981}, {"source": "9", "target": "13", "distance": 0.529599, "similarity": 0.470401, "layout_distance": 0.508478, "relative_similarity": -0.026633}, {"source": "9", "target": "14", "distance": 0.437433, "similarity": 0.562567, "layout_distance": 0.495669, "relative_similarity": 0.013605}, {"source": "9", "target": "15", "distance": 0.584178, "similarity": 0.415822, "layout_distance": 0.560411, "relative_similarity": -0.188651}, {"source": "9", "target": "16", "distance": 0.57532, "similarity": 0.42468, "layout_distance": 0.533338, "relative_similarity": -0.104542}, {"source": "10", "target": "11", "distance": 0.44809, "similarity": 0.55191, "layout_distance": 0.471919, "relative_similarity": 0.088105}, {"source": "10", "target": "12", "distance": 0.565553, "similarity": 0.434447, "layout_distance": 0.55768, "relative_similarity": -0.180218}, {"source": "10", "target": "13", "distance": 0.446646, "similarity": 0.553354, "layout_distance": 0.456441, "relative_similarity": 0.136419}, {"source": "10", "target": "14", "distance": 0.451001, "similarity": 0.548999, "layout_distance": 0.504583, "relative_similarity": -0.014399}, {"source": "10", "target": "15", "distance": 0.581214, "similarity": 0.418786, "layout_distance": 0.557531, "relative_similarity": -0.179756}, {"source": "10", "target": "16", "distance": 0.609104, "similarity": 0.390896, "layout_distance": 0.553356, "relative_similarity": -0.166839}, {"source": "11", "target": "12", "distance": 0.493843, "similarity": 0.506157, "layout_distance": 0.50747, "relative_similarity": -0.023466}, {"source": "11", "target": "13", "distance": 0.563648, "similarity": 0.436352, "layout_distance": 0.526522, "relative_similarity": -0.083224}, {"source": "11", "target": "14", "distance": 0.525043, "similarity": 0.474957, "layout_distance": 0.555364, "relative_similarity": -0.173054}, {"source": "11", "target": "15", "distance": 0.575352, "similarity": 0.424648, "layout_distance": 0.551161, "relative_similarity": -0.160037}, {"source": "11", "target": "16", "distance": 0.562118, "similarity": 0.437882, "layout_distance": 0.522243, "relative_similarity": -0.069823}, {"source": "12", "target": "13", "distance": 0.476643, "similarity": 0.523357, "layout_distance": 0.480157, "relative_similarity": 0.062297}, {"source": "12", "target": "14", "distance": 0.435095, "similarity": 0.564905, "layout_distance": 0.499505, "relative_similarity": 0.001556}, {"source": "12", "target": "15", "distance": 0.543062, "similarity": 0.456938, "layout_distance": 0.539104, "relative_similarity": -0.122539}, {"source": "12", "target": "16", "distance": 0.529058, "similarity": 0.470942, "layout_distance": 0.5098, "relative_similarity": -0.030781}, {"source": "13", "target": "14", "distance": 0.381902, "similarity": 0.618098, "layout_distance": 0.437208, "relative_similarity": 0.19599}, {"source": "13", "target": "15", "distance": 0.663648, "similarity": 0.336352, "layout_distance": 0.587838, "relative_similarity": -0.272462}, {"source": "13", "target": "16", "distance": 0.647595, "similarity": 0.352405, "layout_distance": 0.55597, "relative_similarity": -0.174931}, {"source": "14", "target": "15", "distance": 0.473113, "similarity": 0.526887, "layout_distance": 0.517033, "relative_similarity": -0.053485}, {"source": "14", "target": "16", "distance": 0.552145, "similarity": 0.447855, "layout_distance": 0.549663, "relative_similarity": -0.15539}, {"source": "15", "target": "16", "distance": 0.504004, "similarity": 0.495996, "layout_distance": 0.48622, "relative_similarity": 0.043279}]}, "meta": {"top_k": 3, "clusters": [{"id": 0, "size": 2, "label": "Republican institutional reformers", "rationale": "Both are Republican\u2011oriented doctrines focused on state\u2011centered secularism and reconfiguring Republican institutions and norms.", "member_ids": ["0", "12"], "exemplar_id": "0", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Kemalizm", "\u0130kinci Cumhuriyet\u00e7ilik"], "exemplar_label": "Kemalizm", "representative_ids": ["0", "12"], "representative_labels": ["Kemalizm", "\u0130kinci Cumhuriyet\u00e7ilik"]}, {"id": 1, "size": 6, "label": "Moderate electoral democratic traditions", "rationale": "All members are mainstream centre or centre\u2011left/centre\u2011right electoral currents stressing democratic practice, moderate reform, and market/social policy synthesis.", "member_ids": ["13", "10", "4", "14", "9", "7"], "exemplar_id": "4", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Demokrat Parti Gelene\u011fi", "Demokratik Sol", "Merkez sa\u011f", "Muhafazak\u00e2r Demokrasi", "Ortan\u0131n Solu", "Sosyal demokrasi"], "exemplar_label": "Merkez sa\u011f", "representative_ids": ["4", "9"], "representative_labels": ["Merkez sa\u011f", "Ortan\u0131n Solu"]}, {"id": 2, "size": 9, "label": "Ideological and activist political movements", "rationale": "Each entry is an organized ideological current or activist movement advocating a specific geopolitical, ethnic, religious, nationalist, or revolutionary program.", "member_ids": ["16", "11", "8", "6", "5", "2", "15", "1", "3"], "exemplar_id": "3", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Avrasyac\u0131l\u0131k", "Devrimci Yol", "K\u00fcrt hareketi", "Mill\u00ee G\u00f6r\u00fc\u015f", "Siyasal \u0130slam", "T\u00fcrk milliyet\u00e7ili\u011fi", "T\u00fcrk-\u0130slam Sentezi", "Ulusalc\u0131l\u0131k", "\u00dclk\u00fcc\u00fcl\u00fck"], "exemplar_label": "\u00dclk\u00fcc\u00fcl\u00fck", "representative_ids": ["3", "11"], "representative_labels": ["\u00dclk\u00fcc\u00fcl\u00fck", "Devrimci Yol"]}], "threshold": 0.42, "edge_count": 33, "input_mode": "concept_list", "node_count": 17, "final_count": 17, "input_count": 17, "layout_model": "set_centered_angular_mds_v1", "weight_curve": "square", "cluster_count": 3, "cluster_method": "average_linkage_fixed_count_v1", "distance_count": 136, "expanded_count": 0, "expansion_mode": "contextual_hybrid", "described_count": 17, "distance_metric": "cosine", "embedding_model": "text-embedding-3-large", "expansion_model": "", "generation_model": "gpt-5-mini", "centering_applied": true, "generation_source": "ai_seed", "projection_method": "classical_mds_2d", "projection_stress": 0.3454800326157355, "relationship_mode": "clustered", "anchor_suggestions": [{"label": "Secularism vs. Religiosity", "rationale": "degree to which public life and institutions are organized around secular norms versus religious authority and practice"}, {"label": "State\u2011Centric Order vs. Plural Autonomy", "rationale": "preference for strong centralized state control and unitary order contrasted with decentralization, minority rights, and autonomous social spheres"}, {"label": "Ethno\u2011national Exclusivity vs. Civic Inclusivity", "rationale": "tension between defining the polity by ethnic/cultural homogeneity and defining it by civic, legal, or territorial membership"}, {"label": "Reformist Modernization vs. Traditionalist Continuity", "rationale": "orientation toward transformative, often technocratic modernizing projects versus preserving traditional social, cultural, or religious continuities"}], "cluster_silhouette": 0.08053934406387721, "embedding_provider": "openai", "centering_min_items": 4, "embedding_dimensions": 1024, "embedding_input_type": "default", "cluster_label_version": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "coordinate_max_radius": 0.52, "relative_vector_model": "set_centered_l2_residuals", "cluster_min_silhouette": 0.08, "cluster_selection_mode": "fixed_count", "layout_distance_metric": "angular_distance_acos_over_pi", "embedding_input_version": "label_description_v1", "neighbor_preservation_k": 3, "relationship_mode_label": "Clustered", "requested_cluster_count": 3, "neighbor_preservation_at_3": 0.6274509803921569, "relative_similarity_metric": "cosine", "description_context_version": "semantic_neighborhood_single_sense_v2", "embedding_provider_requested": "openai", "projection_positive_eigenvalues": 16, "anchor": {"id": "9c525458-eea2-44b3-bbe0-b79e830c1574", "label": "Devlet", "model": "text-embedding-3-large", "provider": "openai", "rank_method": "descending_similarity", "score_method": "within_map_min_max", "similarity_max": 0.463093, "similarity_min": 0.302171, "similarity_metric": "cosine"}}, "anchors": [{"id": "9c525458-eea2-44b3-bbe0-b79e830c1574", "label": "Devlet", "visibility": "public", "scope": "map", "is_default": true, "is_mine": false, "can_delete": false, "can_set_default": false}], "active_anchor_id": "9c525458-eea2-44b3-bbe0-b79e830c1574", "anchor_limit": 20}