{"public_id": "36cc038e-d8f1-42d7-b462-8e055f7bc190", "version": 2, "title": "World Religions \u2014 comparative taxonomy (balanced)", "owner": {"username": "onurmatik", "display_name": "onurmatik"}, "published_at": "2026-08-09T18:10:37.389000+00:00", "is_owner": false, "is_latest": true, "forked_from": null, "graph": {"meta": {"top_k": 4, "clusters": [{"id": 0, "size": 7, "label": "Local indigenous and ritual traditions", "rationale": "Centered on local spirits, ritual practices, cultural rites, or regional revivalist identities (animistic, shrine, and folk-oriented systems).", "member_ids": ["14", "8", "13", "12", "7", "10", "9"], "exemplar_id": "14", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Animizm", "Konf\u00fc\u00e7y\u00fcs\u00e7\u00fcl\u00fck", "Neopaganizm", "Rastafaryanl\u0131k", "Taoizm", "Zerd\u00fc\u015ftl\u00fck", "\u015einto"], "exemplar_label": "Animizm", "representative_ids": ["14", "9"], "representative_labels": ["Animizm", "\u015einto"]}, {"id": 1, "size": 5, "label": "Universalizing spiritual and soteriological traditions", "rationale": "Traditions presenting broad soteriological teachings or universalist claims (Dharmic liberation paths and a faith teaching progressive revelation).", "member_ids": ["11", "4", "3", "6", "5"], "exemplar_id": "4", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Bahai", "Budizm", "Hinduizm", "Jainizm", "Sihizm"], "exemplar_label": "Budizm", "representative_ids": ["4", "6"], "representative_labels": ["Budizm", "Jainizm"]}, {"id": 2, "size": 3, "label": "Abrahamic religions", "rationale": "Monotheistic traditions focused on prophets, covenant, and scripture (Christianity, Judaism, Islam).", "member_ids": ["0", "2", "1"], "exemplar_id": "0", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Hristiyanl\u0131k", "Yahudilik", "\u0130slam"], "exemplar_label": "Hristiyanl\u0131k", "representative_ids": ["0", "1"], "representative_labels": ["Hristiyanl\u0131k", "\u0130slam"]}], "threshold": 0.35, "edge_count": 39, "input_mode": "concept_list", "node_count": 15, "final_count": 15, "input_count": 15, "layout_model": "set_centered_angular_mds_v1", "weight_curve": "linear", "cluster_count": 3, "cluster_method": "average_linkage_fixed_count_v1", "distance_count": 105, "expanded_count": 0, "expansion_mode": "contextual_hybrid", "described_count": 15, "distance_metric": "cosine", "embedding_model": "text-embedding-3-large", "expansion_model": "", "cluster_variants": [{"clusters": [{"id": 0, "size": 12, "label": "Non\u2011Abrahamic world traditions", "rationale": "Includes Dharmic, East Asian, Iranian, indigenous, and modern movements described as non\u2011Abrahamic belief systems and spiritual traditions.", "member_ids": ["14", "11", "4", "3", "6", "8", "13", "12", "5", "7", "10", "9"], "exemplar_id": "4", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Animizm", "Bahai", "Budizm", "Hinduizm", "Jainizm", "Konf\u00fc\u00e7y\u00fcs\u00e7\u00fcl\u00fck", "Neopaganizm", "Rastafaryanl\u0131k", "Sihizm", "Taoizm", "Zerd\u00fc\u015ftl\u00fck", "\u015einto"], "exemplar_label": "Budizm", "representative_ids": ["4", "6"], "representative_labels": ["Budizm", "Jainizm"]}, {"id": 1, "size": 3, "label": "Abrahamic religions", "rationale": "Monotheistic faiths centered on covenantal or prophetic revelation (Judaism, Christianity, Islam) and shared scripture/prophetic frameworks.", "member_ids": ["0", "2", "1"], "exemplar_id": "0", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Hristiyanl\u0131k", "Yahudilik", "\u0130slam"], "exemplar_label": "Hristiyanl\u0131k", "representative_ids": ["0", "1"], "representative_labels": ["Hristiyanl\u0131k", "\u0130slam"]}], "cluster_count": 2, "cluster_method": "average_linkage_fixed_count_v1", "cluster_silhouette": 0.07649259260773691, "cluster_min_silhouette": 0.08, "cluster_selection_mode": "fixed_count", "requested_cluster_count": 2}, {"clusters": [{"id": 0, "size": 7, "label": "Local indigenous and ritual traditions", "rationale": "Centered on local spirits, ritual practices, cultural rites, or regional revivalist identities (animistic, shrine, and folk-oriented systems).", "member_ids": ["14", "8", "13", "12", "7", "10", "9"], "exemplar_id": "14", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Animizm", "Konf\u00fc\u00e7y\u00fcs\u00e7\u00fcl\u00fck", "Neopaganizm", "Rastafaryanl\u0131k", "Taoizm", "Zerd\u00fc\u015ftl\u00fck", "\u015einto"], "exemplar_label": "Animizm", "representative_ids": ["14", "9"], "representative_labels": ["Animizm", "\u015einto"]}, {"id": 1, "size": 5, "label": "Universalizing spiritual and soteriological traditions", "rationale": "Traditions presenting broad soteriological teachings or universalist claims (Dharmic liberation paths and a faith teaching progressive revelation).", "member_ids": ["11", "4", "3", "6", "5"], "exemplar_id": "4", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Bahai", "Budizm", "Hinduizm", "Jainizm", "Sihizm"], "exemplar_label": "Budizm", "representative_ids": ["4", "6"], "representative_labels": ["Budizm", "Jainizm"]}, {"id": 2, "size": 3, "label": "Abrahamic religions", "rationale": "Monotheistic traditions focused on prophets, covenant, and scripture (Christianity, Judaism, Islam).", "member_ids": ["0", "2", "1"], "exemplar_id": "0", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Hristiyanl\u0131k", "Yahudilik", "\u0130slam"], "exemplar_label": "Hristiyanl\u0131k", "representative_ids": ["0", "1"], "representative_labels": ["Hristiyanl\u0131k", "\u0130slam"]}], "cluster_count": 3, "cluster_method": "average_linkage_fixed_count_v1", "cluster_silhouette": 0.09262335591894626, "cluster_min_silhouette": 0.08, "cluster_selection_mode": "fixed_count", "requested_cluster_count": 3}, {"clusters": [{"id": 0, "size": 4, "label": "Nature\u2011centered and revivalist traditions", "rationale": "Described as animistic, nature\u2011centered, or modern revivalist movements inspired by pre\u2011Christian or indigenous practices.", "member_ids": ["14", "13", "12", "9"], "exemplar_id": "14", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Animizm", "Neopaganizm", "Rastafaryanl\u0131k", "\u015einto"], "exemplar_label": "Animizm", "representative_ids": ["14", "9"], "representative_labels": ["Animizm", "\u015einto"]}, {"id": 1, "size": 5, "label": "Major Asian\u2011origin and universalist religions", "rationale": "Originating in South or East Asia (Dharmic and related faiths) or presenting broad, universalist religious teachings.", "member_ids": ["11", "4", "3", "6", "5"], "exemplar_id": "4", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Bahai", "Budizm", "Hinduizm", "Jainizm", "Sihizm"], "exemplar_label": "Budizm", "representative_ids": ["4", "6"], "representative_labels": ["Budizm", "Jainizm"]}, {"id": 2, "size": 3, "label": "Abrahamic religions", "rationale": "Monotheistic, scripture\u2011centered faiths built around prophetic or covenantal identities.", "member_ids": ["0", "2", "1"], "exemplar_id": "0", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Hristiyanl\u0131k", "Yahudilik", "\u0130slam"], "exemplar_label": "Hristiyanl\u0131k", "representative_ids": ["0", "1"], "representative_labels": ["Hristiyanl\u0131k", "\u0130slam"]}, {"id": 3, "size": 3, "label": "Classical Eurasian ethical\u2011philosophies", "rationale": "Ancient or classical systems emphasizing ethical, philosophical, and cosmological teachings from China and Iran.", "member_ids": ["8", "7", "10"], "exemplar_id": "8", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Konf\u00fc\u00e7y\u00fcs\u00e7\u00fcl\u00fck", "Taoizm", "Zerd\u00fc\u015ftl\u00fck"], "exemplar_label": "Konf\u00fc\u00e7y\u00fcs\u00e7\u00fcl\u00fck", "representative_ids": ["8", "7"], "representative_labels": ["Konf\u00fc\u00e7y\u00fcs\u00e7\u00fcl\u00fck", "Taoizm"]}], "cluster_count": 4, "cluster_method": "average_linkage_fixed_count_v1", "cluster_silhouette": 0.10983206925616153, "cluster_min_silhouette": 0.08, "cluster_selection_mode": "fixed_count", "requested_cluster_count": 4}], "generation_model": "gpt-5-mini", "centering_applied": true, "generation_source": "draft_sidebar", "projection_method": "classical_mds_2d", "projection_stress": 0.3564483847256243, "relationship_mode": "balanced", "anchor_suggestions": [{"label": "Sacred Authority", "rationale": "degree to which truth and practice are anchored to an external revealed/personified authority (prophet, scripture, deity) versus diffuse or immanent sources"}, {"label": "Transcendence vs. Immanence", "rationale": "emphasis on a distant, otherworldly ultimate reality compared with divinity or sacredness pervading the world and nature"}, {"label": "Communal Ritual vs. Individual Path", "rationale": "orientation toward shared, institutionalized rites and community identity versus individualized practice, meditation, or personal ethical striving"}, {"label": "Orthopraxy vs. Orthodoxy", "rationale": "priority of correct practice/ritual and social norms over correct belief/doctrine (and vice versa)"}], "cluster_silhouette": 0.09262335591894626, "embedding_provider": "openai", "centering_min_items": 4, "embedding_dimensions": 1024, "embedding_input_type": "default", "cluster_label_version": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "coordinate_max_radius": 0.52, "default_cluster_count": 3, "relative_vector_model": "set_centered_l2_residuals", "cluster_min_silhouette": 0.08, "cluster_selection_mode": "fixed_count", "layout_distance_metric": "angular_distance_acos_over_pi", "embedding_input_version": "label_description_v1", "neighbor_preservation_k": 3, "relationship_mode_label": "Balanced", "requested_cluster_count": 3, "neighbor_preservation_at_3": 0.6, "relative_similarity_metric": "cosine", "description_context_version": "semantic_neighborhood_single_sense_v2", "embedding_provider_requested": "openai", "projection_positive_eigenvalues": 14, "anchor": {"id": "124e28eb-2a6e-4df7-a241-028b413366cf", "label": "Ateizm", "model": "text-embedding-3-large", "provider": "openai", "rank_method": "descending_similarity", "score_method": "within_map_min_max", "similarity_max": 0.449375, "similarity_min": 0.196738, "similarity_metric": "cosine"}}, "edges": [{"source": "4", "target": "6", "weight": 0.673104, "similarity": 0.673104}, {"source": "0", "target": "1", "weight": 0.632482, "similarity": 0.632482}, {"source": "3", "target": "6", "weight": 0.630106, "similarity": 0.630106}, {"source": "3", "target": "4", "weight": 0.624381, "similarity": 0.624381}, {"source": "3", "target": "5", "weight": 0.590843, "similarity": 0.590843}, {"source": "0", "target": "2", "weight": 0.580912, "similarity": 0.580912}, {"source": "9", "target": "14", "weight": 0.558489, "similarity": 0.558489}, {"source": "1", "target": "2", "weight": 0.551846, "similarity": 0.551846}, {"source": "4", "target": "7", "weight": 0.536372, "similarity": 0.536372}, {"source": "4", "target": "5", "weight": 0.526156, "similarity": 0.526156}, {"source": "6", "target": "7", "weight": 0.517745, "similarity": 0.517745}, {"source": "13", "target": "14", "weight": 0.5163, "similarity": 0.5163}, {"source": "7", "target": "8", "weight": 0.515271, "similarity": 0.515271}, {"source": "5", "target": "11", "weight": 0.50265, "similarity": 0.50265}, {"source": "1", "target": "5", "weight": 0.489616, "similarity": 0.489616}, {"source": "5", "target": "6", "weight": 0.483497, "similarity": 0.483497}, {"source": "4", "target": "10", "weight": 0.478705, "similarity": 0.478705}, {"source": "7", "target": "10", "weight": 0.478052, "similarity": 0.478052}, {"source": "5", "target": "10", "weight": 0.476249, "similarity": 0.476249}, {"source": "7", "target": "9", "weight": 0.46913, "similarity": 0.46913}, {"source": "1", "target": "11", "weight": 0.466111, "similarity": 0.466111}, {"source": "7", "target": "14", "weight": 0.464139, "similarity": 0.464139}, {"source": "3", "target": "14", "weight": 0.463957, "similarity": 0.463957}, {"source": "10", "target": "11", "weight": 0.452137, "similarity": 0.452137}, {"source": "2", "target": "3", "weight": 0.447767, "similarity": 0.447767}, {"source": "3", "target": "11", "weight": 0.442214, "similarity": 0.442214}, {"source": "2", "target": "10", "weight": 0.431495, "similarity": 0.431495}, {"source": "3", "target": "9", "weight": 0.428654, "similarity": 0.428654}, {"source": "2", "target": "12", "weight": 0.426231, "similarity": 0.426231}, {"source": "6", "target": "9", "weight": 0.423953, "similarity": 0.423953}, {"source": "3", "target": "13", "weight": 0.420665, "similarity": 0.420665}, {"source": "12", "target": "13", "weight": 0.417644, "similarity": 0.417644}, {"source": "0", "target": "10", "weight": 0.416222, "similarity": 0.416222}, {"source": "0", "target": "11", "weight": 0.410241, "similarity": 0.410241}, {"source": "12", "target": "14", "weight": 0.400829, "similarity": 0.400829}, {"source": "11", "target": "12", "weight": 0.399843, "similarity": 0.399843}, {"source": "9", "target": "13", "weight": 0.393391, "similarity": 0.393391}, {"source": "8", "target": "10", "weight": 0.370284, "similarity": 0.370284}, {"source": "2", "target": "8", "weight": 0.364036, "similarity": 0.364036}], "nodes": [{"x": 0.52, "y": 0.0, "id": "0", "label": "Hristiyanl\u0131k", "degree": 4, "source": "user", "cluster": 2, "description": "Abrahamic religion; monotheistic belief centered on Jesus as savior and texts like the Bible; major branches include Catholicism, Orthodoxy, Protestantism.", "anchor_similarity": 0.406577, "anchor_score": 0.830594, "anchor_rank": 2}, {"x": 0.470937, "y": 0.163324, "id": "1", "label": "\u0130slam", "degree": 4, "source": "user", "cluster": 2, "description": "Abrahamic religion; monotheistic belief centered on Muhammad as prophet and the Quran as scripture; major branches Sunni and Shia.", "anchor_similarity": 0.323046, "anchor_score": 0.499959, "anchor_rank": 10}, {"x": 0.374214, "y": -0.062338, "id": "2", "label": "Yahudilik", "degree": 6, "source": "user", "cluster": 2, "description": "Abrahamic religion; ethno-religious tradition centered on covenantal Judaism, Torah law, and practices of Jewish community and identity.", "anchor_similarity": 0.315595, "anchor_score": 0.470467, "anchor_rank": 11}, {"x": -0.192816, "y": 0.396497, "id": "3", "label": "Hinduizm", "degree": 8, "source": "user", "cluster": 1, "description": "Dharmic religion-family; diverse polytheistic and philosophical traditions originating in South Asia, centers on dharma, karma, samsara, and multiple scriptures.", "anchor_similarity": 0.324358, "anchor_score": 0.505151, "anchor_rank": 9}, {"x": -0.376095, "y": 0.323304, "id": "4", "label": "Budizm", "degree": 5, "source": "user", "cluster": 1, "description": "Dharmic tradition; non-theistic soteriology focused on the Four Noble Truths, the Eightfold Path, karma, and liberation (nirvana).", "anchor_similarity": 0.385845, "anchor_score": 0.748532, "anchor_rank": 4}, {"x": -0.036055, "y": 0.399614, "id": "5", "label": "Sihizm", "degree": 6, "source": "user", "cluster": 1, "description": "South Asian monotheistic religion; founded in 15th-century Punjab, emphasizes belief in one God, teachings of the Gurus, community service, and scripture (Guru Granth Sahib).", "anchor_similarity": 0.310547, "anchor_score": 0.450483, "anchor_rank": 12}, {"x": -0.392786, "y": 0.270422, "id": "6", "label": "Jainizm", "degree": 5, "source": "user", "cluster": 1, "description": "Dharmic religion; non-theistic tradition from India emphasizing strict nonviolence (ahimsa), asceticism, karma, and liberation of the soul.", "anchor_similarity": 0.328851, "anchor_score": 0.522938, "anchor_rank": 8}, {"x": -0.359254, "y": -0.161088, "id": "7", "label": "Taoizm", "degree": 6, "source": "user", "cluster": 0, "description": "Chinese philosophical-religious tradition; focuses on the Dao (the Way), harmony with nature, wu wei (non-action), and texts like the Tao Te Ching.", "anchor_similarity": 0.333198, "anchor_score": 0.540144, "anchor_rank": 7}, {"x": -0.090318, "y": -0.307541, "id": "8", "label": "Konf\u00fc\u00e7y\u00fcs\u00e7\u00fcl\u00fck", "degree": 3, "source": "user", "cluster": 0, "description": "Chinese ethical-philosophical tradition; emphasizes social harmony, ritual propriety, filial piety, and teachings attributed to Confucius.", "anchor_similarity": 0.196738, "anchor_score": 0.0, "anchor_rank": 15}, {"x": -0.143732, "y": -0.339999, "id": "9", "label": "\u015einto", "degree": 5, "source": "user", "cluster": 0, "description": "Japanese indigenous religion; animistic and ritual tradition centered on kami (spirits), shrine worship, and seasonal rites.", "anchor_similarity": 0.342657, "anchor_score": 0.577584, "anchor_rank": 5}, {"x": 0.002001, "y": -0.026214, "id": "10", "label": "Zerd\u00fc\u015ftl\u00fck", "degree": 7, "source": "user", "cluster": 0, "description": "Ancient Iranian religion; dualistic faith founded by Zoroaster centered on Ahura Mazda, cosmic struggle between truth and falsehood, and moral choice.", "anchor_similarity": 0.449375, "anchor_score": 1.0, "anchor_rank": 1}, {"x": 0.224788, "y": 0.175801, "id": "11", "label": "Bahai", "degree": 6, "source": "user", "cluster": 1, "description": "Independent world religion; emerged in 19th-century Persia, teaches unity of religions and humanity, progressive revelation through multiple messengers.", "anchor_similarity": 0.294167, "anchor_score": 0.385647, "anchor_rank": 14}, {"x": 0.171068, "y": -0.231957, "id": "12", "label": "Rastafaryanl\u0131k", "degree": 4, "source": "user", "cluster": 0, "description": "Modern religious movement; Afrocentric faith from Jamaica combining Ethiopianism, Pan-African ideas, reverence for Haile Selassie, and reggae cultural elements.", "anchor_similarity": 0.336421, "anchor_score": 0.552899, "anchor_rank": 6}, {"x": -0.013819, "y": -0.249015, "id": "13", "label": "Neopaganizm", "degree": 4, "source": "user", "cluster": 0, "description": "Contemporary revivalist religious movements; reconstructed or eclectic practices inspired by pre-Christian European paganisms, often nature-centered and polytheistic.", "anchor_similarity": 0.297864, "anchor_score": 0.400281, "anchor_rank": 13}, {"x": -0.15813, "y": -0.350811, "id": "14", "label": "Animizm", "degree": 5, "source": "user", "cluster": 0, "description": "Religious-ethnographic category; belief systems attributing spiritual agency or personhood to animals, plants, objects, and natural phenomena.", "anchor_similarity": 0.40429, "anchor_score": 0.821543, "anchor_rank": 3}], "distances": [{"source": "0", "target": "1", "distance": 0.367518, "similarity": 0.632482, "layout_distance": 0.386698, "relative_similarity": 0.348481}, {"source": "0", "target": "2", "distance": 0.419088, "similarity": 0.580912, "layout_distance": 0.425705, "relative_similarity": 0.231292}, {"source": "0", "target": "3", "distance": 0.599485, "similarity": 0.400515, "layout_distance": 0.553098, "relative_similarity": -0.166039}, {"source": "0", "target": "4", "distance": 0.628516, "similarity": 0.371484, "layout_distance": 0.560434, "relative_similarity": -0.188721}, {"source": "0", "target": "5", "distance": 0.633124, "similarity": 0.366876, "layout_distance": 0.549759, "relative_similarity": -0.155686}, {"source": "0", "target": "6", "distance": 0.700875, "similarity": 0.299125, "layout_distance": 0.591912, "relative_similarity": -0.284753}, {"source": "0", "target": "7", "distance": 0.692112, "similarity": 0.307888, "layout_distance": 0.58803, "relative_similarity": -0.273043}, {"source": "0", "target": "8", "distance": 0.705802, "similarity": 0.294198, "layout_distance": 0.518929, "relative_similarity": -0.059431}, {"source": "0", "target": "9", "distance": 0.635868, "similarity": 0.364132, "layout_distance": 0.541899, "relative_similarity": -0.131251}, {"source": "0", "target": "10", "distance": 0.583778, "similarity": 0.416222, "layout_distance": 0.519518, "relative_similarity": -0.06128}, {"source": "0", "target": "11", "distance": 0.589759, "similarity": 0.410241, "layout_distance": 0.510335, "relative_similarity": -0.032463}, {"source": "0", "target": "12", "distance": 0.610016, "similarity": 0.389984, "layout_distance": 0.500472, "relative_similarity": -0.001483}, {"source": "0", "target": "13", "distance": 0.664066, "similarity": 0.335934, "layout_distance": 0.529368, "relative_similarity": -0.092132}, {"source": "0", "target": "14", "distance": 0.657855, "similarity": 0.342145, "layout_distance": 0.558881, "relative_similarity": -0.183926}, {"source": "1", "target": "2", "distance": 0.448154, "similarity": 0.551846, "layout_distance": 0.44848, "relative_similarity": 0.161148}, {"source": "1", "target": "3", "distance": 0.538147, "similarity": 0.461853, "layout_distance": 0.521778, "relative_similarity": -0.068364}, {"source": "1", "target": "4", "distance": 0.648811, "similarity": 0.351189, "layout_distance": 0.581221, "relative_similarity": -0.252403}, {"source": "1", "target": "5", "distance": 0.510384, "similarity": 0.489616, "layout_distance": 0.484116, "relative_similarity": 0.04988}, {"source": "1", "target": "6", "distance": 0.654088, "similarity": 0.345912, "layout_distance": 0.571533, "relative_similarity": -0.222842}, {"source": "1", "target": "7", "distance": 0.626989, "similarity": 0.373011, "layout_distance": 0.556395, "relative_similarity": -0.176246}, {"source": "1", "target": "8", "distance": 0.777821, "similarity": 0.222179, "layout_distance": 0.560318, "relative_similarity": -0.188364}, {"source": "1", "target": "9", "distance": 0.611425, "similarity": 0.388575, "layout_distance": 0.53475, "relative_similarity": -0.108953}, {"source": "1", "target": "10", "distance": 0.594175, "similarity": 0.405825, "layout_distance": 0.532426, "relative_similarity": -0.101694}, {"source": "1", "target": "11", "distance": 0.533889, "similarity": 0.466111, "layout_distance": 0.484903, "relative_similarity": 0.047412}, {"source": "1", "target": "12", "distance": 0.681994, "similarity": 0.318006, "layout_distance": 0.544766, "relative_similarity": -0.140174}, {"source": "1", "target": "13", "distance": 0.702537, "similarity": 0.297463, "layout_distance": 0.55649, "relative_similarity": -0.176539}, {"source": "1", "target": "14", "distance": 0.630585, "similarity": 0.369415, "layout_distance": 0.550234, "relative_similarity": -0.157162}, {"source": "2", "target": "3", "distance": 0.552233, "similarity": 0.447767, "layout_distance": 0.544533, "relative_similarity": -0.139448}, {"source": "2", "target": "4", "distance": 0.599444, "similarity": 0.400556, "layout_distance": 0.564398, "relative_similarity": -0.200935}, {"source": "2", "target": "5", "distance": 0.635965, "similarity": 0.364035, "layout_distance": 0.573081, "relative_similarity": -0.22758}, {"source": "2", "target": "6", "distance": 0.578064, "similarity": 0.421936, "layout_distance": 0.538485, "relative_similarity": -0.120609}, {"source": "2", "target": "7", "distance": 0.607742, "similarity": 0.392258, "layout_distance": 0.55838, "relative_similarity": -0.182379}, {"source": "2", "target": "8", "distance": 0.635964, "similarity": 0.364036, "layout_distance": 0.499621, "relative_similarity": 0.00119}, {"source": "2", "target": "9", "distance": 0.600638, "similarity": 0.399362, "layout_distance": 0.541032, "relative_similarity": -0.12855}, {"source": "2", "target": "10", "distance": 0.568505, "similarity": 0.431495, "layout_distance": 0.529572, "relative_similarity": -0.092771}, {"source": "2", "target": "11", "distance": 0.572349, "similarity": 0.427651, "layout_distance": 0.518254, "relative_similarity": -0.057314}, {"source": "2", "target": "12", "distance": 0.573769, "similarity": 0.426231, "layout_distance": 0.496965, "relative_similarity": 0.009534}, {"source": "2", "target": "13", "distance": 0.646003, "similarity": 0.353997, "layout_distance": 0.537599, "relative_similarity": -0.117845}, {"source": "2", "target": "14", "distance": 0.602085, "similarity": 0.397915, "layout_distance": 0.546321, "relative_similarity": -0.145008}, {"source": "3", "target": "4", "distance": 0.375619, "similarity": 0.624381, "layout_distance": 0.436234, "relative_similarity": 0.198988}, {"source": "3", "target": "5", "distance": 0.409157, "similarity": 0.590843, "layout_distance": 0.448363, "relative_similarity": 0.161512}, {"source": "3", "target": "6", "distance": 0.369894, "similarity": 0.630106, "layout_distance": 0.423292, "relative_similarity": 0.238659}, {"source": "3", "target": "7", "distance": 0.546965, "similarity": 0.453035, "layout_distance": 0.541841, "relative_similarity": -0.13107}, {"source": "3", "target": "8", "distance": 0.724344, "similarity": 0.275656, "layout_distance": 0.564394, "relative_similarity": -0.200922}, {"source": "3", "target": "9", "distance": 0.571346, "similarity": 0.428654, "layout_distance": 0.544357, "relative_similarity": -0.138902}, {"source": "3", "target": "10", "distance": 0.573135, "similarity": 0.426865, "layout_distance": 0.554467, "relative_similarity": -0.170279}, {"source": "3", "target": "11", "distance": 0.557786, "similarity": 0.442214, "layout_distance": 0.529336, "relative_similarity": -0.09203}, {"source": "3", "target": "12", "distance": 0.651794, "similarity": 0.348206, "layout_distance": 0.560914, "relative_similarity": -0.190202}, {"source": "3", "target": "13", "distance": 0.579335, "similarity": 0.420665, "layout_distance": 0.518513, "relative_similarity": -0.058128}, {"source": "3", "target": "14", "distance": 0.536043, "similarity": 0.463957, "layout_distance": 0.52614, "relative_similarity": -0.082029}, {"source": "4", "target": "5", "distance": 0.473844, "similarity": 0.526156, "layout_distance": 0.48202, "relative_similarity": 0.056456}, {"source": "4", "target": "6", "distance": 0.326896, "similarity": 0.673104, "layout_distance": 0.387423, "relative_similarity": 0.346344}, {"source": "4", "target": "7", "distance": 0.463628, "similarity": 0.536372, "layout_distance": 0.477938, "relative_similarity": 0.069255}, {"source": "4", "target": "8", "distance": 0.678489, "similarity": 0.321511, "layout_distance": 0.530369, "relative_similarity": -0.095263}, {"source": "4", "target": "9", "distance": 0.578359, "similarity": 0.421641, "layout_distance": 0.538389, "relative_similarity": -0.120311}, {"source": "4", "target": "10", "distance": 0.521295, "similarity": 0.478705, "layout_distance": 0.510704, "relative_similarity": -0.03362}, {"source": "4", "target": "11", "distance": 0.575018, "similarity": 0.424982, "layout_distance": 0.530158, "relative_similarity": -0.094603}, {"source": "4", "target": "12", "distance": 0.694559, "similarity": 0.305441, "layout_distance": 0.575595, "relative_similarity": -0.235261}, {"source": "4", "target": "13", "distance": 0.647633, "similarity": 0.352367, "layout_distance": 0.548934, "relative_similarity": -0.153125}, {"source": "4", "target": "14", "distance": 0.589534, "similarity": 0.410466, "layout_distance": 0.549943, "relative_similarity": -0.156257}, {"source": "5", "target": "6", "distance": 0.516503, "similarity": 0.483497, "layout_distance": 0.498571, "relative_similarity": 0.00449}, {"source": "5", "target": "7", "distance": 0.565948, "similarity": 0.434052, "layout_distance": 0.530193, "relative_similarity": -0.094713}, {"source": "5", "target": "8", "distance": 0.783879, "similarity": 0.216121, "layout_distance": 0.573669, "relative_similarity": -0.229379}, {"source": "5", "target": "9", "distance": 0.606263, "similarity": 0.393737, "layout_distance": 0.54238, "relative_similarity": -0.132746}, {"source": "5", "target": "10", "distance": 0.523751, "similarity": 0.476249, "layout_distance": 0.500317, "relative_similarity": -0.000997}, {"source": "5", "target": "11", "distance": 0.49735, "similarity": 0.50265, "layout_distance": 0.472461, "relative_similarity": 0.086409}, {"source": "5", "target": "12", "distance": 0.646322, "similarity": 0.353678, "layout_distance": 0.5353, "relative_similarity": -0.110671}, {"source": "5", "target": "13", "distance": 0.675526, "similarity": 0.324474, "layout_distance": 0.55214, "relative_similarity": -0.163071}, {"source": "5", "target": "14", "distance": 0.60676, "similarity": 0.39324, "layout_distance": 0.547081, "relative_similarity": -0.147371}, {"source": "6", "target": "7", "distance": 0.482255, "similarity": 0.517745, "layout_distance": 0.479883, "relative_similarity": 0.063157}, {"source": "6", "target": "8", "distance": 0.728952, "similarity": 0.271048, "layout_distance": 0.546688, "relative_similarity": -0.14615}, {"source": "6", "target": "9", "distance": 0.576047, "similarity": 0.423953, "layout_distance": 0.525735, "relative_similarity": -0.080762}, {"source": "6", "target": "10", "distance": 0.583933, "similarity": 0.416067, "layout_distance": 0.538537, "relative_similarity": -0.120773}, {"source": "6", "target": "11", "distance": 0.630866, "similarity": 0.369134, "layout_distance": 0.552398, "relative_similarity": -0.163872}, {"source": "6", "target": "12", "distance": 0.654257, "similarity": 0.345743, "layout_distance": 0.541098, "relative_similarity": -0.128755}, {"source": "6", "target": "13", "distance": 0.670824, "similarity": 0.329176, "layout_distance": 0.550974, "relative_similarity": -0.159455}, {"source": "6", "target": "14", "distance": 0.578054, "similarity": 0.421946, "layout_distance": 0.531146, "relative_similarity": -0.097693}, {"source": "7", "target": "8", "distance": 0.484729, "similarity": 0.515271, "layout_distance": 0.422212, "relative_similarity": 0.241952}, {"source": "7", "target": "9", "distance": 0.53087, "similarity": 0.46913, "layout_distance": 0.499819, "relative_similarity": 0.000568}, {"source": "7", "target": "10", "distance": 0.521948, "similarity": 0.478052, "layout_distance": 0.501708, "relative_similarity": -0.005366}, {"source": "7", "target": "11", "distance": 0.630243, "similarity": 0.369757, "layout_distance": 0.553321, "relative_similarity": -0.166731}, {"source": "7", "target": "12", "distance": 0.706337, "similarity": 0.293663, "layout_distance": 0.571614, "relative_similarity": -0.22309}, {"source": "7", "target": "13", "distance": 0.628157, "similarity": 0.371843, "layout_distance": 0.528324, "relative_similarity": -0.088865}, {"source": "7", "target": "14", "distance": 0.535861, "similarity": 0.464139, "layout_distance": 0.506731, "relative_similarity": -0.021144}, {"source": "8", "target": "9", "distance": 0.655348, "similarity": 0.344652, "layout_distance": 0.500724, "relative_similarity": -0.002274}, {"source": "8", "target": "10", "distance": 0.629716, "similarity": 0.370284, "layout_distance": 0.49387, "relative_similarity": 0.019258}, {"source": "8", "target": "11", "distance": 0.765347, "similarity": 0.234653, "layout_distance": 0.549865, "relative_similarity": -0.156016}, {"source": "8", "target": "12", "distance": 0.744146, "similarity": 0.255854, "layout_distance": 0.519726, "relative_similarity": -0.061932}, {"source": "8", "target": "13", "distance": 0.836218, "similarity": 0.163782, "layout_distance": 0.562621, "relative_similarity": -0.195463}, {"source": "8", "target": "14", "distance": 0.713659, "similarity": 0.286341, "layout_distance": 0.533084, "relative_similarity": -0.103749}, {"source": "9", "target": "10", "distance": 0.587939, "similarity": 0.412061, "layout_distance": 0.529976, "relative_similarity": -0.094034}, {"source": "9", "target": "11", "distance": 0.680516, "similarity": 0.319484, "layout_distance": 0.570095, "relative_similarity": -0.218433}, {"source": "9", "target": "12", "distance": 0.614846, "similarity": 0.385154, "layout_distance": 0.509861, "relative_similarity": -0.030975}, {"source": "9", "target": "13", "distance": 0.606609, "similarity": 0.393391, "layout_distance": 0.50599, "relative_similarity": -0.018818}, {"source": "9", "target": "14", "distance": 0.441511, "similarity": 0.558489, "layout_distance": 0.44014, "relative_similarity": 0.186949}, {"source": "10", "target": "11", "distance": 0.547863, "similarity": 0.452137, "layout_distance": 0.500782, "relative_similarity": -0.002456}, {"source": "10", "target": "12", "distance": 0.642925, "similarity": 0.357075, "layout_distance": 0.532083, "relative_similarity": -0.100621}, {"source": "10", "target": "13", "distance": 0.651913, "similarity": 0.348087, "layout_distance": 0.537638, "relative_similarity": -0.117967}, {"source": "10", "target": "14", "distance": 0.586581, "similarity": 0.413419, "layout_distance": 0.533373, "relative_similarity": -0.104652}, {"source": "11", "target": "12", "distance": 0.600157, "similarity": 0.399843, "layout_distance": 0.497167, "relative_similarity": 0.008898}, {"source": "11", "target": "13", "distance": 0.612898, "similarity": 0.387102, "layout_distance": 0.504407, "relative_similarity": -0.013846}, {"source": "11", "target": "14", "distance": 0.640129, "similarity": 0.359871, "layout_distance": 0.550972, "relative_similarity": -0.15945}, {"source": "12", "target": "13", "distance": 0.582356, "similarity": 0.417644, "layout_distance": 0.470186, "relative_similarity": 0.093528}, {"source": "12", "target": "14", "distance": 0.599171, "similarity": 0.400829, "layout_distance": 0.504955, "relative_similarity": -0.015565}, {"source": "13", "target": "14", "distance": 0.4837, "similarity": 0.5163, "layout_distance": 0.44254, "relative_similarity": 0.179536}]}, "meta": {"top_k": 4, "clusters": [{"id": 0, "size": 7, "label": "Local indigenous and ritual traditions", "rationale": "Centered on local spirits, ritual practices, cultural rites, or regional revivalist identities (animistic, shrine, and folk-oriented systems).", "member_ids": ["14", "8", "13", "12", "7", "10", "9"], "exemplar_id": "14", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Animizm", "Konf\u00fc\u00e7y\u00fcs\u00e7\u00fcl\u00fck", "Neopaganizm", "Rastafaryanl\u0131k", "Taoizm", "Zerd\u00fc\u015ftl\u00fck", "\u015einto"], "exemplar_label": "Animizm", "representative_ids": ["14", "9"], "representative_labels": ["Animizm", "\u015einto"]}, {"id": 1, "size": 5, "label": "Universalizing spiritual and soteriological traditions", "rationale": "Traditions presenting broad soteriological teachings or universalist claims (Dharmic liberation paths and a faith teaching progressive revelation).", "member_ids": ["11", "4", "3", "6", "5"], "exemplar_id": "4", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Bahai", "Budizm", "Hinduizm", "Jainizm", "Sihizm"], "exemplar_label": "Budizm", "representative_ids": ["4", "6"], "representative_labels": ["Budizm", "Jainizm"]}, {"id": 2, "size": 3, "label": "Abrahamic religions", "rationale": "Monotheistic traditions focused on prophets, covenant, and scripture (Christianity, Judaism, Islam).", "member_ids": ["0", "2", "1"], "exemplar_id": "0", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Hristiyanl\u0131k", "Yahudilik", "\u0130slam"], "exemplar_label": "Hristiyanl\u0131k", "representative_ids": ["0", "1"], "representative_labels": ["Hristiyanl\u0131k", "\u0130slam"]}], "threshold": 0.35, "edge_count": 39, "input_mode": "concept_list", "node_count": 15, "final_count": 15, "input_count": 15, "layout_model": "set_centered_angular_mds_v1", "weight_curve": "linear", "cluster_count": 3, "cluster_method": "average_linkage_fixed_count_v1", "distance_count": 105, "expanded_count": 0, "expansion_mode": "contextual_hybrid", "described_count": 15, "distance_metric": "cosine", "embedding_model": "text-embedding-3-large", "expansion_model": "", "cluster_variants": [{"clusters": [{"id": 0, "size": 12, "label": "Non\u2011Abrahamic world traditions", "rationale": "Includes Dharmic, East Asian, Iranian, indigenous, and modern movements described as non\u2011Abrahamic belief systems and spiritual traditions.", "member_ids": ["14", "11", "4", "3", "6", "8", "13", "12", "5", "7", "10", "9"], "exemplar_id": "4", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Animizm", "Bahai", "Budizm", "Hinduizm", "Jainizm", "Konf\u00fc\u00e7y\u00fcs\u00e7\u00fcl\u00fck", "Neopaganizm", "Rastafaryanl\u0131k", "Sihizm", "Taoizm", "Zerd\u00fc\u015ftl\u00fck", "\u015einto"], "exemplar_label": "Budizm", "representative_ids": ["4", "6"], "representative_labels": ["Budizm", "Jainizm"]}, {"id": 1, "size": 3, "label": "Abrahamic religions", "rationale": "Monotheistic faiths centered on covenantal or prophetic revelation (Judaism, Christianity, Islam) and shared scripture/prophetic frameworks.", "member_ids": ["0", "2", "1"], "exemplar_id": "0", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Hristiyanl\u0131k", "Yahudilik", "\u0130slam"], "exemplar_label": "Hristiyanl\u0131k", "representative_ids": ["0", "1"], "representative_labels": ["Hristiyanl\u0131k", "\u0130slam"]}], "cluster_count": 2, "cluster_method": "average_linkage_fixed_count_v1", "cluster_silhouette": 0.07649259260773691, "cluster_min_silhouette": 0.08, "cluster_selection_mode": "fixed_count", "requested_cluster_count": 2}, {"clusters": [{"id": 0, "size": 7, "label": "Local indigenous and ritual traditions", "rationale": "Centered on local spirits, ritual practices, cultural rites, or regional revivalist identities (animistic, shrine, and folk-oriented systems).", "member_ids": ["14", "8", "13", "12", "7", "10", "9"], "exemplar_id": "14", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Animizm", "Konf\u00fc\u00e7y\u00fcs\u00e7\u00fcl\u00fck", "Neopaganizm", "Rastafaryanl\u0131k", "Taoizm", "Zerd\u00fc\u015ftl\u00fck", "\u015einto"], "exemplar_label": "Animizm", "representative_ids": ["14", "9"], "representative_labels": ["Animizm", "\u015einto"]}, {"id": 1, "size": 5, "label": "Universalizing spiritual and soteriological traditions", "rationale": "Traditions presenting broad soteriological teachings or universalist claims (Dharmic liberation paths and a faith teaching progressive revelation).", "member_ids": ["11", "4", "3", "6", "5"], "exemplar_id": "4", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Bahai", "Budizm", "Hinduizm", "Jainizm", "Sihizm"], "exemplar_label": "Budizm", "representative_ids": ["4", "6"], "representative_labels": ["Budizm", "Jainizm"]}, {"id": 2, "size": 3, "label": "Abrahamic religions", "rationale": "Monotheistic traditions focused on prophets, covenant, and scripture (Christianity, Judaism, Islam).", "member_ids": ["0", "2", "1"], "exemplar_id": "0", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Hristiyanl\u0131k", "Yahudilik", "\u0130slam"], "exemplar_label": "Hristiyanl\u0131k", "representative_ids": ["0", "1"], "representative_labels": ["Hristiyanl\u0131k", "\u0130slam"]}], "cluster_count": 3, "cluster_method": "average_linkage_fixed_count_v1", "cluster_silhouette": 0.09262335591894626, "cluster_min_silhouette": 0.08, "cluster_selection_mode": "fixed_count", "requested_cluster_count": 3}, {"clusters": [{"id": 0, "size": 4, "label": "Nature\u2011centered and revivalist traditions", "rationale": "Described as animistic, nature\u2011centered, or modern revivalist movements inspired by pre\u2011Christian or indigenous practices.", "member_ids": ["14", "13", "12", "9"], "exemplar_id": "14", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Animizm", "Neopaganizm", "Rastafaryanl\u0131k", "\u015einto"], "exemplar_label": "Animizm", "representative_ids": ["14", "9"], "representative_labels": ["Animizm", "\u015einto"]}, {"id": 1, "size": 5, "label": "Major Asian\u2011origin and universalist religions", "rationale": "Originating in South or East Asia (Dharmic and related faiths) or presenting broad, universalist religious teachings.", "member_ids": ["11", "4", "3", "6", "5"], "exemplar_id": "4", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Bahai", "Budizm", "Hinduizm", "Jainizm", "Sihizm"], "exemplar_label": "Budizm", "representative_ids": ["4", "6"], "representative_labels": ["Budizm", "Jainizm"]}, {"id": 2, "size": 3, "label": "Abrahamic religions", "rationale": "Monotheistic, scripture\u2011centered faiths built around prophetic or covenantal identities.", "member_ids": ["0", "2", "1"], "exemplar_id": "0", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Hristiyanl\u0131k", "Yahudilik", "\u0130slam"], "exemplar_label": "Hristiyanl\u0131k", "representative_ids": ["0", "1"], "representative_labels": ["Hristiyanl\u0131k", "\u0130slam"]}, {"id": 3, "size": 3, "label": "Classical Eurasian ethical\u2011philosophies", "rationale": "Ancient or classical systems emphasizing ethical, philosophical, and cosmological teachings from China and Iran.", "member_ids": ["8", "7", "10"], "exemplar_id": "8", "label_source": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "member_labels": ["Konf\u00fc\u00e7y\u00fcs\u00e7\u00fcl\u00fck", "Taoizm", "Zerd\u00fc\u015ftl\u00fck"], "exemplar_label": "Konf\u00fc\u00e7y\u00fcs\u00e7\u00fcl\u00fck", "representative_ids": ["8", "7"], "representative_labels": ["Konf\u00fc\u00e7y\u00fcs\u00e7\u00fcl\u00fck", "Taoizm"]}], "cluster_count": 4, "cluster_method": "average_linkage_fixed_count_v1", "cluster_silhouette": 0.10983206925616153, "cluster_min_silhouette": 0.08, "cluster_selection_mode": "fixed_count", "requested_cluster_count": 4}], "generation_model": "gpt-5-mini", "centering_applied": true, "generation_source": "draft_sidebar", "projection_method": "classical_mds_2d", "projection_stress": 0.3564483847256243, "relationship_mode": "balanced", "anchor_suggestions": [{"label": "Sacred Authority", "rationale": "degree to which truth and practice are anchored to an external revealed/personified authority (prophet, scripture, deity) versus diffuse or immanent sources"}, {"label": "Transcendence vs. Immanence", "rationale": "emphasis on a distant, otherworldly ultimate reality compared with divinity or sacredness pervading the world and nature"}, {"label": "Communal Ritual vs. Individual Path", "rationale": "orientation toward shared, institutionalized rites and community identity versus individualized practice, meditation, or personal ethical striving"}, {"label": "Orthopraxy vs. Orthodoxy", "rationale": "priority of correct practice/ritual and social norms over correct belief/doctrine (and vice versa)"}], "cluster_silhouette": 0.09262335591894626, "embedding_provider": "openai", "centering_min_items": 4, "embedding_dimensions": 1024, "embedding_input_type": "default", "cluster_label_version": "ai_discriminative_cluster_labels_v1", "coordinate_max_radius": 0.52, "default_cluster_count": 3, "relative_vector_model": "set_centered_l2_residuals", "cluster_min_silhouette": 0.08, "cluster_selection_mode": "fixed_count", "layout_distance_metric": "angular_distance_acos_over_pi", "embedding_input_version": "label_description_v1", "neighbor_preservation_k": 3, "relationship_mode_label": "Balanced", "requested_cluster_count": 3, "neighbor_preservation_at_3": 0.6, "relative_similarity_metric": "cosine", "description_context_version": "semantic_neighborhood_single_sense_v2", "embedding_provider_requested": "openai", "projection_positive_eigenvalues": 14, "anchor": {"id": "124e28eb-2a6e-4df7-a241-028b413366cf", "label": "Ateizm", "model": "text-embedding-3-large", "provider": "openai", "rank_method": "descending_similarity", "score_method": "within_map_min_max", "similarity_max": 0.449375, "similarity_min": 0.196738, "similarity_metric": "cosine"}}, "anchors": [{"id": "124e28eb-2a6e-4df7-a241-028b413366cf", "label": "Ateizm", "visibility": "public", "scope": "map", "is_default": true, "is_mine": false, "can_delete": false, "can_set_default": false}], "active_anchor_id": "124e28eb-2a6e-4df7-a241-028b413366cf", "anchor_limit": 20}